I won't be doing a lot of these. But since I'm getting this started here, I figured I'd take these and use them for something to start with, anyhow!
His live performances, however, are always zen-like, he gets so far into the Moment of performing, he carries you along. Add to that the fact that his audiences are a true cross-section of American life (with a little foreign flavor always tagging along) and generations and you have a true phenomenon, only comparable to what Grateful Dead concerts were like- only Bob's audiences are much What Bob has done with this recording however, is to take some of the songs he left off both the latest albums, and some of the songs he included, and polished them and left them to shine on their own. I happen to enjoy these one-off type of recordings because they catch him in different poses and attitudes, and I think, in many ways, that this is an album I will play much more often than Love and Theft or Modern Times simply because it's a little more honest, a little less slick, and there's some songs on it that would have been better than the selections made for the albums in question, even.
Without going into a track-by track analysis (which I consider a review technique a little too "b-anal" for my sis), I would like to mention the cuts I like better than the album selections first- these are- The first Mississippi outtake, Red River Shore, Born in Time, Marchin' to the City, Can't Escape From You, God Knows, Huck's Tune, and Cross the Green Mountain. All of these might have taken the place over droll tunes he rarely (if ever!) plays live like Po' Boy or Floater and the overdone Nettie Moore and Workingman's Blues 2. Those two are a guaranteed snooze for me) at the shows…
For the tracks I prefer to their album counterparts, again, the aforementioned Mississippi take 1 from Time Out of Mind, Someday Baby, Ain't Talkin and High Water (live.) these all rock and/or make the musical statement in ways the albums cannot measure up to… With the addition of a couple more trad oriented tracks, like 32-20 Blues and The Lonesome River, which features bluegrass great Ralph Stanley, the whole package adds up to a variety pack of spice-o-life entrees.
In fact, I would not be surprised if I never played those two albums again and contented myself with the two disks of the set that I bought!
Dylan is a one of a kind, much imitated, far-influencing, and his place in history is assured. Albums like this are excellent additions to the legacy because they allow people to see the process of change and re-write he often applies, and also the way arrangements change in sometimes unexpected, powerful ways. "Ring Them Bells (live)" is one such example- while the Oh Mercy track is a bare skeleton, the live performance is something else again.
I'm committed to going to Bob's concerts -til I get a live performance of Mr. Tambourine Man- but as I said, these two disks are a great complement or even improvement over the last two albums. The Lord worketh in mysterieth ways- & so doth the Bob.